For all the financial scandal that ultimately attached to the two and a half years of the Harding presidency, chiefly symbolized in the infamous Teapot Dome affair, most historians do not accuse the president personally of corruption or even of tolerating the antics of his political associates. Phoebe Carolyn Votaw (born Harding) in MyHeritage family trees (Levesque Web Site) Behind the CurtainIf Warren G. Harding had not been intimately connected with Seventh-day Adventists through blood and history, it is doubtful that church leaders would have found much to praise in the nation?s twenty-ninth president. In December 1921 he was commended--in a full-page open letter signed by General Conference president A. G. Daniells, treasurer W. T. Knox, and secretary J. L. Shaw--for his efforts ?in behalf of international peace and tranquillity. Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Dec. 8, 1921, p. 2.17 Ibid. Both left office within a year of President Harding’s 1923 death from a heart attack. Harding?s brother, George, Jr., established a successful psychiatric hospital in Columbus, which he operated for many years. Sawyer?s long association with both Warren and Florence Harding brought him increased prominence as the president?s personal physician when the Hardings moved into the White House. Preaching an ambiguous ?return to normalcy? In December 1921 he was commended--in a full-page open letter signed by General Conference president A. G. Daniells, treasurer W. T. Knox, and secretary J. L. Shaw--for his efforts ?in behalf of international peace and tranquillity.? urged Review and Herald associate editor C. A. Holt in a column three weeks after the Republican president?s sudden death in August 1923, ?and second, upon the ability of men who write the record to estimate the times and their needs.?1. The document clearly and forcefully articulated the church?s interest in limiting armaments and thus diminishing the prospects for international conflicts. that ?endeared him to all classes.? [3] They moved to Washington while Harding was a U.S. Presidential appointee Charles R. Forbes, head of the Veterans Bureau, had resigned his post in February of that year and fled to Europe when details of his corrupt dealings with government contractors came to light and a primary attorney in his agency committed suicide. Choosing to discount the persistent stories of extramarital affairs that had dogged Harding?s political career for more than 20 years, the, In a highly unusual tribute to the deceased leader, the, On one level, the effusive praise for President Harding was the understandable reaction of an editorial team that, like the rest of the nation, was shocked at the news of the leader?s sudden death in San Francisco on August 2. SNAC is a discovery service for persons, families, and organizations found within archival collections at cultural heritage institutions. Carolyn Harding Votaw is similar to these topics: Warren G. Harding, Takoma (Washington, D.C.), Attempted assassination of Ronald Reagan and more. Harding and his wife had also introduced elements of popular culture into the White House that must have caused Adventist leaders no end of private discomfort. At a time when most Baptists advocated abstinence from alcohol, and when federal law made the possession of alcohol for other than medicinal purposes illegal, Harding drank whiskey or brandy daily, and even served it to guests and visitors at his poker games in the White House. The other American presidents--Republicans all--who had died in office since the founding of the magazine [Lincoln (1865), Garfield (1881), and McKinley (1901)] had all been victims of assassination, unquestionably a more devastating blow to the national psyche. She lived in Burma from 1905-1914 where husband Herber Votaw (standing behind her) was an Adventist Minister. As a young adult, Harding himself had shown little interest in the Adventist Church, preferring instead a more carefree lifestyle than that recommended for Adventist young men. Occasional and brief references to the nearly Adventist president replaced the superlatives that had once been so much used. His public friendship with the president?s Adventist sister, Carolyn, and her minister husband, Heber, had occasioned much criticism in the popular press. Frete GRÁTIS em milhares de produtos com o Amazon Prime. How the COVID-19 pandemic placed one nurse in a position to make a difference. ?6, Choosing to discount the persistent stories of extramarital affairs that had dogged Harding?s political career for more than 20 years, the Review had proclaimed him ?a loving husband, a kind neighbor, a wise counselor.?7. Review editors were certainly well aware of the nature of presidential declarations on all manner of topics intended primarily for political consumption. Changing Times at Sydney Adventist Hospital Bring Restructuring, Cuts Born into a devout Baptist family in Blooming Grove, Ohio, just after the close of the Civil War, Harding was a teenager away at Ohio Central College when his mother, Phoebe, and his aunt, Sarah Priscilla Flack, joined the Adventist Church in 1879. George Tryon Harding 1844 – 1928. If Warren G. Harding had not been intimately connected with Seventh-day Adventists through blood and history, it is doubtful that church leaders would have found much to praise in the nation?s twenty-ninth president. Daniel was born on September 19 1809, in Moore, North Carolina, United States. All in the FamilyOn one level, the effusive praise for President Harding was the understandable reaction of an editorial team that, like the rest of the nation, was shocked at the news of the leader?s sudden death in San Francisco on August 2. in the world of Adventism, but apparently not for the famous relative of Adventists. YB1946 Harding proved a popular candidate on the stump, and won the 1914 Senate election, taking his seat when the Sixty-fourth Congress convened in 1915. Harding had clung to ?simplicity of life. The Hardings were the first presidential couple to openly embrace jazz music and modern dancing. and Republican Party unity. It requires more than just words. Move seeks to position Adventist HealthCare to attain its vision under the new reality. ?18 Ten weeks before his death Harding was similarly praised in conjunction with his graduation visit to Washington Missionary College: ?His loyalty to the Holy Scriptures in these days of subtle skepticism, and his interest in Christian service are well known by all who have made note of his public utterances.?19. Any minority religious group, especially one whose distinctive beliefs put it frequently at variance with majority culture regarding the appropriate day of worship, Christian lifestyle, and the bearing of arms in wartime, is liable to find the magnetic pull of increased respectability and public approbation nearly irresistible. Encontre diversos livros em Inglês e Outras Línguas com ótimos preços. He had conducted his campaign for the presidency, they wrote, ?on a dignified plan, befitting the character of a Christian gentleman.?15. He was known to smoke an average of two cigars a day, in addition to using chewing tobacco whenever his wife was not around. Children PARENTS AND SIBLINGS. Front and CenterTwo weeks after the November 1920 presidential election, Review and Herald editors seemed to no longer need to be cautious about the president-elect. Four generations of Hardings (and a total of 27 individuals) have now served the church and the nation as physicians, 13 of them as psychiatrists. Senator from Ohio. Bodyguard’s Silent Witness Helps Convert Commanding Officer Harding?s predecessor, Woodrow Wilson, had twice been pictured on the cover--once in connection with a call for Bible study, and a second time when he headed the American delegation to the peace conference after World War I.His written messages to the nation during the war had several times appeared there. 1844-1928. A Bible Strategy for Racial Bridge Building Religious Liberty Department, where he worked for the next 28 years, including 13 as editor of Liberty magazine.23. Six other Ohioans in Harding?s lifetime--all Republicans--had succeeded in capturing the White House, and the state?s pivotal role in national elections gave its politicians a ?leg up? Ministry Their house was on Lower Kemmendine, near the Lady Dufferin Hospital (now Central … Carolyn?s husband, Heber H. Votaw, an Adventist minister who had served with her in mission work in Burma from 1905 to 1914, was currently serving as director of the Federal Prison System, though he had no professional training or experience in such work. A plan for the establshment of a hospital for the 80,000 Government employes In Washington is being con- In Washington is being con- Some biographers point to his ?modest, self-effacing manner? President Harding and his wife, Florence, had attended nephew George?s graduation at the college on May 20, 1923, a visit duly noted and lauded in the Review. In December of that year he announced his candidacy for the Republican nomination. [10] She arranged a tour of the White House for Nan Britton, with whom Harding allegedly had an extensive affair, and their child, Elizabeth Britton. Sawyer?s untraditional methods and close guarding of the president?s medical condition and history may have contributed, however,to Harding?s deterioration during what is now recognized as a cardiac event that afflicted the president in August 1923. The initial outpouring of public grief for the first president to die of natural causes in more than 80 years was quickly tempered by the drumbeat of scandalous revelations about the men with whom he had surrounded himself during his political and presidential career. List of Seventh-day Adventists at popflock.com America?s reluctant entry into World War I and the massive changes the war effort caused in American life provided Harding with a ?bully pulpit? the journal reported, ?although Americans generally seem to have very little intimate knowledge concerning his character, abilities, or achievements.? Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Aug. 23, 1923, p. 2. volume in 1927 entitled The President?s Daughter, and in the mid-1960s, when correspondence between Harding and his Marion, Ohio, neighbor, Carrie Phillips, revealed the significance of their 15-year affair. Though he lost his first bid for elective office (county auditor) in 1895, he succeeded in winning a seat as a state senator in 1899. On the golf course, to which he resorted at least twice a week, the president was known to make so many bets that he sometimes inadvertently ended up betting against himself. From 1903 onward he turned for medical counsel and advice to Dr. Charles Sawyer, who operated a sanitarium near Harding?s boyhood home in Marion. Soon after her brother was elected to the presidency in 1920, she was appointed to head the social service division of the U.S. Public Health Service,[6][7] while her husband was named by Attorney General Harry M. Daugherty as Superintendent of Prisons and chairman of the boards of parole at each institution. Presidential appointee Charles R. Forbes, head of the Veterans Bureau, had resigned his post in February of that year and fled to Europe when details of his corrupt dealings with government contractors came to light and a primary attorney in his agency committed suicide. Harding?s five-year career in the U.S. Senate was undistinguished by almost all accounts. View Videos or join the discussion. [8][9] Mrs. Votaw also served as an advisor to the Federal Board of Vocation Education within the Veterans’ Bureau, which caused her name to arise during testimony in the successful prosecution of the Bureau’s director, Charles R. Forbes, on corruption charges. He was ?a man of noble, generous impulses.? Aug 1, 2014 - Americans and Burmese friends, Rangoon 1914. If you have any questions, or need the bot to ignore the links, or the page altogether, please visit this simple FaQ for additional information. The favorable press in the church?s main journal continued throughout the Harding presidency. A regime change, a revolution, even an orderly and democratic election, can so change the political landscape that the church is left isolated and vulnerable to its critics, and must spend years rebuilding its reputation as being chiefly committed to a kingdom not of this world. Brother-in-law Heber Votaw returned to church employ in 1925 after unproved allegations that he had allowed an illegal drug-smuggling operation to exist within the Atlanta Federal penitentiary. It was the dead president?s close family ties to the Seventh-day Adventist Church, both in his native Midwest and in the nation?s capital, however, that made the loss seem doubly dear, for the church?s informal access to the seat of American political power would inevitably now be greatly diminished. Edit your search or learn more. and probusiness philosophy. He was, by all accounts, diligent in doing the people?s business, even though he keenly felt his inadequacies for a job whose complexities frequently bewildered him. Includes letters from Florence Kling Harding to Catherine McLean Brown New. From a dozen entanglements through the decades with dictators, presidents, prime ministers, and politburos, Adventists have learned that the seeming luster of association with the politically powerful is fleeting at best, and too often damages the cause itself by alienating other political forces or aligning the church with one faction within a nation or region. [11], In 1924, after President Harding died in office, Heber Votaw's integrity was challenged in a U.S. Senate hearing on misconduct within the Daugherty Department of Justice. and eager to preserve American sovereignty from ?foreign entanglements? ​On Fire for China A plan for the establshment of a hospital for the 80,000 Government employes In Washington is being con sidered by Mrs. Carolyn Harding Votaw, sister of the late President Harding, who, it became known last night, will leave the United States Tublic Health Service March 15. I have just modified one external link on Carolyn Harding Votaw. According to the editors, ?he has been compared to McKinley? As a young adult, Harding himself had shown little interest in the Adventist Church, preferring instead a more carefree lifestyle than that recommended for Adventist young men. ©Copyright 2021, Adventist Review. ?In marked contrast to the tinsel and. She was born in Caledonia, Ohio, in 1879,[1] and graduated from high school in Marion, Ohio, in 1898. [12] He resigned the following year, citing ill health. Carolyn Cunningham Jerome Finney Kourtney Glover Domonique Gray-Berroa Jalondra Jones Cody Ketter ... Courtney C. Harding Jennifer M. Jolly Courtney N. Knight Robbie Kuykendall Katy S. Lalla ... Teresa (Buff) Votaw Traci K. (Maffett) Wardorf Gretchen (Shaw) Zimmerman 1987-1988. Indeed, his overwork during 1923 was deemed a probable cause, both popularly and medically, for the heart attack that claimed his life on August 2, 1923. show, the hypocrisy and cant, of much of present-day living,? He certainly also does not bear responsibility for the ways in which Adventist writers and leaders lionized him, frequently beyond the bounds of good judgment. ?17 A delegation of church leaders, including Review editor Wilcox, presented the document to Harding personally at a November 25 White House event after introductions by Elder Heber Votaw, the president?s brother-in-law. Find a Grave, database and images (https://www.findagrave.com: accessed ), memorial page for Phoebe Carolyn Harding Votaw (21 Oct 1879–21 Oct 1951), Find a Grave Memorial no. He was, by all accounts, diligent in doing the people?s business, even though he keenly felt his inadequacies for a job whose complexities frequently bewildered him. The woman seated in the middle is Carolyn Harding Votaw, younger sister of Warren Harding, the 29th President of the United States. Add List of Seventh-day Adventists to your PopFlock.com topic list or share. Harding?s five-year career in the U.S. Senate was undistinguished by almost all accounts. Two weeks after the November 1920 presidential election, When Harding was sworn in as the nation?s twenty-ninth president on March 4, 1921, the. SPOUSES AND CHILDREN. He certainly also does not bear responsibility for the ways in which Adventist writers and leaders lionized him, frequently beyond the bounds of good judgment. 1881-1962. The apostle Paul, who also stood before councils, kings, and emperors, provided the church with timeless counsel: ?Consider your own call, brothers and sisters: not many of you were wise by human standards, not many were powerful, not many were of noble birth. But the magazine had never entered so daringly into the political world of its host city as when Francis Wilcox and his editorial team signaled the special relationship between the new president and the church by giving him the front cover of the church?s flagship periodical the day before his inauguration. There the dead president had been lauded for his ?honesty and integrity,? Fall?s leasing of government oil reserves to large oil corporations was already under investigation by a Senate committee.4 Attorney general Harry Daugherty?s questionable connections to both government contractors and bootleggers were prompting calls for congressional investigations.5, Holt could write safely only of Harding?s ?homelier virtues,? How an army officer in Angola became an Adventist church elder. Lessons LearnedThe tale of the nearly Adventist president is a cautionary one, for it underscores the temptations to which a religious movement is subject when it is granted access to politically powerful personalities. Warren G. Harding papers, 1908-1926 285 items ; 3 containers plus 1 oversize ; 2 linear feet. for advancing his agenda of ?Americanism? Never before--and never since--have any of the seven other American presidents who died in office been so honored. Bruce Wayne Harding 02 May 1957 New South Wales, Australia - 10 May 2011 . HOSPITAL FOR U. S. EMPLOYES URGED Mrs. Votaw Proposes Estab- lishment Here to Be Main- tained by Workers. The tale of the nearly Adventist president is a cautionary one, for it underscores the temptations to which a religious movement is subject when it is granted access to politically powerful personalities. Both of Harding?s parents were homeopathic physicians, and throughout his life the future president remained interested in homeopathic remedies. memorialized one week earlier in a black-bordered column on the masthead page of the Review. On five separate occasions over a 14-year span, however (1889, twice in 1894, 1897, and 1903), Harding had traveled from central Ohio to Dr. John Harvey Kellogg?s famed Battle Creek Sanitarium for treatment of depression, anxiety, or nervous breakdown, the last visit coming after he had already made his entry into Ohio Republican politics. The painful reality is, however, that though church leaders and members naturally enough crave public acceptance, believing that the increased public notice will bring the church?s message to a larger audience, the price of consorting with political leaders is usually higher than the church can afford to pay. The couple did not have children. [13], The Votaws lived at 7633 Carroll Avenue in Takoma Park, Maryland.[14]. She was born in Caledonia, Ohio, in 1879, and graduated from high school in Marion, Ohio, in 1898. His poker games, mostly with political cronies and friends also originally from Ohio, were legendary: stories circulating around the capital had it that the president had actually gambled away an entire set of the White House china during one late-night session. Marriage: 29 April 1863. They also welcomed Hollywood stars to campaign with them, and later, to visit them at the White House. Any minority religious group, especially one whose distinctive beliefs put it frequently at variance with majority culture regarding the appropriate day of worship, Christian lifestyle, and the bearing of arms in wartime, is liable to find the magnetic pull of increased respectability and public approbation nearly irresistible. The Votaw House is the official home of the President of Washington University. Phoebe Carolyn Harding Votaw (October 21, 1879 – October 22, 1951) the youngest sister of Warren G. Harding, 29th President of the United States, was a missionary, then a public officeholder in Washington D.C. before and during his administration. Eyes on the PrizeWarren Harding?s rise to political prominence in his native Ohio was propelled by his successful role as editor and publisher of the Marion Star, a once-struggling local newspaper that he developed into a strong regional voice for Republican Party politics. Mary E. Votaw was born on month day 1901, at birth place, Kansas, to Edson B. Votaw and Sarah E. "Ella S." Votaw (born Clearwater). His son, George III, directed the Harding Hospital from 1934 to 1973, and additionally served as president of the College of Medical Evangelists (now Loma Linda University) from 1948-1951. Move seeks to position Adventist HealthCare to attain its vision under the new reality. Week of Prayer seeks to equip and empower them to minister in difficult times. professional footsteps as a physician and was now a prominent Adventist doctor operating a mental health sanitarium in suburban Columbus, Ohio. Compre online Presidency of Warren G. Harding: Warren G. Harding, List of federal judges appointed by Warren G. Harding, Carolyn Harding Votaw, Judson Welliver, de Source: Wikipedia na Amazon. He had, the column continued, a ?kindly, courteous bearing? How an army officer in Angola became an Adventist church elder. Edit Search New search. 7 Conclusive evidence of Harding?s liaisons with other women did not emerge until years after his death, when Nan Britton published a ?tell-all? Caroline Harding in household of G T Harding, "United States Census, 1900" Family Members. But. He was known to smoke an average of two cigars a day, in addition to using chewing tobacco whenever his wife was not around. William J. Burns, then the head of the Bureau of Investigation, alleged that Votaw called him off an investigation of a narcotics smuggling ring at Atlanta Federal Penitentiary, fearing the adverse publicity it would generate. Biographers point to as many as four other women with whom Harding was involved. candidate Harding, whose partisans had astutely been preparing for just such a possibility. As the Harding legacy began to crumble, the. His great mistake, according to most historians, was that he trusted those who proved unworthy of his confidence. Carol Jean Votaw, age 53, Rochester Hills, MI 48306 View Full Report Known Locations: Rochester Hills MI, 48306, Beverly Hills MI 48025, Birmingham MI 48009 Possible Relatives: Carol J Votaw, Richard A Votaw, Scott Allan Votaw Florence Harding regularly consulted a D.C. astrologer, Madame Marcia, to discern the most favorable moments for planning major events of the presidential calendar. Always a preacher of party unity who made himself available to all Republican factions, Harding was tapped by fellow Ohioan President William Howard Taft to place Taft?s name in nomination at the 1912 Republican National Convention. such as Woodrow Wilson?s cherished League of Nations, Americans seemed more than ready for a man known to have ?the common touch.? 1:26-29, NRSV)._________________________ 1 C. A. Holt, ?Comment on Current Events,? On the golf course, to which he resorted at least twice a week, the president was known to make so many bets that he sometimes inadvertently ended up betting against himself.21. THE SUNDAY STAR, WASHINGTON, D. C., FEBRUARY 15, 1925-PAKT 1. He served two years in the Federal Penitentiary at Fort Leavenworth, Kansas. ?18 Francis M. Wilcox, ?President Harding and Religion? Numerous politicians on the national level were beginning to speculate on the amiable politician?s chances for the presidency. (versus Wilson?s perceived ?internationalism?) To get better results, add more information such as First Name, Birth Info, Death Info and Location—even a guess will help. 3. Harding has been before the country for many years as one of its leading statesmen,? The couple did not have children. and probusiness philosophy. Gripped by the Right ArmWarren Harding?s personal knowledge of the beliefs and practices of Seventh-day Adventism was more thorough than that of any American president before or since. Adventist leaders already had reason to be dismayed at what was happening to the Harding legacy about which they had said so much, and to fear the assessment of future historians. and eager to preserve American sovereignty from ?foreign entanglements? Edson was born on August 31 1863, in Ohio, United States. (editorial), Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Feb. 22, 1923, pp. But God chose what is foolish in the world to shame the wise; God chose what is weak in the world to shame the strong; God chose what is low and despised in the world, things that are not, to reduce to nothing things that are, so that no one might boast in the presence of God? AbeBooks.com: Warren G. Harding Memorial Address delivered before the Joint meeting of the Two Houses of Congress (INSCRIBED by Harding's sister): Octavo; 94 pp; illustrations. As the Harding legacy began to crumble, the Review and Herald grew silent about the president it had once so publicly admired. that ?endeared him to all classes.? in a campaign largely conducted from his front porch in Marion, Harding swept to the presidency on his fifty-fifth birthday with the largest popular vote majority in the history of the nation to that point--more than 60 percent. The church?s Annual Council, which voted the unusual document, applauded ?the wise statesmanship and humane sentiment which prompt this laudable action. [2] To distinguish her from her mother, Phoebe Dickerson Harding, she was known by her middle name Carolyn. Records show that he failed to attend at least 46 percent of all the roll call votes, especially those on controversial issues. Definitions of Carolyn Harding Votaw, synonyms, antonyms, derivatives of Carolyn Harding Votaw, analogical dictionary of Carolyn Harding Votaw (English) The turn on the national stage certainly did Harding no harm, even though his candidate, Taft, lost the fall election to Democrat Woodrow Wilson, and even trailed former President Theodore Roosevelt, who ran as an independent. Any or all of these practices would have occasioned disciplinary action in a local congregation if an avowed Adventist had been involved: these were, for good or ill, markers of ?character? 3 Forbes was indicted for looting more than $200 million from the government, and tried in 1925 for bribery and corruption. 4 Fall?s subsequent indictment for bribery, conviction, and prison term marked him as the first Cabinet member to go to jail in the history of the country. After the FallFor all the financial scandal that ultimately attached to the two and a half years of the Harding presidency, chiefly symbolized in the infamous Teapot Dome affair, most historians do not accuse the president personally of corruption or even of tolerating the antics of his political associates. The resulting conflicts drove the movement toward direct popular election of senators called for in the amendment.12 Eugene P. Trani and David L. Wilson, The Presidency of Warren G. Harding (Lawrence: University Press of Kansas, 1977), p. 35.13 Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, July 15, 1920, p. 27.14 Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Nov. 18, 1920, p. 16.15 Ibid.16 ?Address to President Harding,? Most Adventists no doubt voted for the senator with the close Adventist connections: their preference for Republican politics stemmed from the church?s early abolitionist stance and advocacy for alcoholic Prohibition, another social goal mostly identified with Republican politics. The youngest of Harding?s siblings, George, Jr., and Carolyn--13 and 14 years younger than he, respectively--had been raised in the new faith, though some accounts suggest that his sisters (Abigail, Mary, and Charity), also embraced Adventism. The reception was attended by much of the University family. 6 Unsigned column, ?President Harding,? Family Members. When the president sent a public letter to the Jewish Jubilee Dinner in February 1923 that praised ?the Hebrew conception of a personal God and of the individual accountability of men and women,? After completing higher studies, Heber H. Votaw and Carolyn Harding (born October 21, 1879), daughter of Dr. and Mrs. George Tryon Harding from Mount Vernon, Ohio, were married in Marion, Ohio, on August 5, 1903. It further identified the church?s historic position of noncombatancy, and stated unequivocally that ?Seventh-day Adventists, therefore, are noncombatant in faith and practice. Mrs. Votaw Proposes Estab lishment Here to Be Main tained by Workers. 71-80.11 Until the ratification of the Seventeenth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution in April 1913 United States senators were chosen by many different methods, according to each state?s laws. the journal opined, contradicting its assertion of three months earlier that he was generally not well known by the electorate.14 Where the editors had previously concluded that little was known by the public about his character and abilities, they now professed direct knowledge: ?He is a man of unblemished character and of sterling integrity.? They had complained repeatedly when former president Wilson, whose electoral victories had been aided by Democratic and Catholic votes, attended a Catholic Mass on Thanksgiving Day, and when Wilson had signed a Sunday observance declaration for the armed forces during wartime at the request of evangelical groups. Dr. George Tryon Harding. New, and Carolyn Harding Votaw. When former president and expected presidential candidate Theodore Roosevelt died suddenly in 1919, Harding?s window to national office opened.
Perfume A Tus Pies, Allie Deberry Instagram, Blue Snowball Australia, Fallout 4 Wireless Conduit, Best Folding Electric Bike Under 1000, H Mart Salmon Roe,